Public Squares, Volunteering and Cultural Differences: When Solidarity Needs Rules

06.10.2026
Gian Andrea Franchi
Gian Andrea Franchi

Living together in public squares is never a neutral fact. A square is not merely a physical space: it is a place of encounter, vulnerability, proximity, trust. When people with very different stories, languages, wounds, social codes and cultural references coexist in that space, the beauty of encounter can also become fatigue. And this fatigue must be named without hypocrisy, but also without slipping into generalisation.

The delicate point is precisely this: not to turn an episode, a discomfort or a conflict into a collective condemnation. No community can be judged by the behaviour of some. At the same time, however, we cannot pretend that cultural differences do not exist. They certainly do. They exist in the way public space is understood, in the relationship between men and women, in the boundary between familiarity and invasion, in the value of a gesture, of a look, of a word, of a joke.

There are behaviours that, in one context, may be perceived as harmless or ambiguous, while in another they become heavy, invasive, even threatening. This does not mean justifying anything. It means understanding that integration is not a rhetorical formula: it is daily, concrete, educational work.

Those who arrive in a different country must know the legal rules, certainly, but also the unwritten social ones: consent, respect for distance, women's freedom, girls' autonomy, the right of every person not to be bothered. But the discourse also applies on the other side: those who decide to volunteer in contexts crossed by strong cultural differences should prepare themselves, inform themselves, understand which relational codes may be misunderstood and which symbolic dynamics may be activated. Not to limit their own freedom, nor to blame women, but to enter that space with greater awareness. In certain contexts, a gesture that for a Western girl is entirely normal, cordial or even insignificant may be read differently by those who come from more rigid, patriarchal social environments or who have been shaped by a different education regarding relations between the sexes. Precisely for this reason, training, cultural mediation and clear rules are needed: not to create walls, but to avoid misunderstandings, protect everyone and make solidarity truly sustainable.

From this point of view, cultural difference cannot become an excuse. Respect is not negotiable. In Italy, as in every democratic legal system, the dignity of the person is the foundation of coexistence: Article 2 of the Constitution says so, when it recognises the inviolable rights of the person and requires the fulfilment of the mandatory duties of political, economic and social solidarity. Article 3 says so, when it affirms equal social dignity without distinction of sex, race, language, religion, political opinions and personal conditions. The entire criminal justice system also says so, in a very concrete way, when it protects personal freedom, moral freedom, safety and sexual dignity.

But precisely because these principles are serious, they cannot be used selectively. The protection of women, female volunteers, vulnerable people or simply those who cross a square must always matter. The protection of migrants, asylum seekers and homeless people must always matter. Security cannot be opposed to solidarity: solidarity without rules wears itself out, but security without humanity becomes nothing but control.

In experiences of proximity, especially in places frequented by migrants and volunteers, a pedagogy of coexistence is needed. Distributing material goods is not enough. It is necessary to explain clearly which behaviours are acceptable and which are not. It is necessary to make people understand that a girl can speak with a man without wanting to establish any relationship; that kindness is not availability; that the female body is not a territory to be interpreted according to patriarchal codes; that the help received does not authorise demands, pressure or forms of possession. But, at the same time, Western girls who choose to enter multicultural volunteering contexts should learn to know and respect the culture of migrant people: not to adapt to models that restrict women's freedom, but to better understand sensitivities, modesty, relational codes, forms of communication and possible misunderstandings. Respecting a culture does not mean accepting every aspect of it uncritically; it means approaching the other without arrogance, knowing that one's own normality is not universal. The point of balance is this: no culture can justify pressure, demands or dynamics of possession, but no helping relationship should arise from ignorance of the inner and symbolic world of the other.

This also applies to those who, on the other side, enter these places with good intentions but without adequate tools. Intercultural relationships require preparation. It is not enough to be generous. One must know that a gesture, a word or closeness can be read differently depending on the personal and cultural history of the person receiving them. Not out of fear, but out of responsibility. Empathy, alone, is not enough: it must be accompanied by lucidity.

When a solidarity network decides to temporarily suspend an activity because it believes that a limit has been crossed, that gesture must not be dismissed as abandonment. On the contrary, it may be an act of responsibility. Saying "we cannot accept what is intolerable" means protecting the very meaning of help. Care cannot be based on the moral blackmail of having to endure everything. Those who help also have the right to a perimeter of safety, respect and dignity.

The risk, naturally, is that similar episodes may immediately be used by those who want to turn every problem into propaganda against migrants. That would be a serious mistake. But it would be an equally serious mistake to leave these issues in the hands of those who exploit them, giving up on speaking about them honestly. The left, volunteering, the world of rights must have the courage to say that welcoming is not do-goodism, it is not improvisation, it is not denial of conflicts. It is a demanding practice, requiring rules, training, cultural mediation, institutional presence and the ability to intervene before discomfort becomes rupture.

A square can truly be "of the world" only if the world that inhabits it accepts a minimum pact: no one dominates the other, no one takes advantage of another's vulnerability, no one uses their own story as authorisation to wound. Cultural differences must not be erased, but they must meet a clear limit: the dignity of the person.

Perhaps it is precisely here that the quality of a civil community is measured. Not in pretending that everything is fine. Not in looking for a collective culprit. But in knowing how to hold together three very difficult things: the protection of those who are vulnerable, respect for those who help and the responsabilisation of those who are welcomed. Without this balance, the square stops being a place of encounter and becomes a place of suspicion. With this balance, instead, it can return to being what it should be: a human, plural, demanding space, where solidarity is not blind, but adult.

Share